SEC wants court to consider Terraform ruling in Binance case – Blockworks
The SEC, in a Wednesday filing, said the recent Terraform ruling is relevant in its case against Binance
Binance co-founder Changpeng Zhao | Stephen McCarthy/Web Summit via Sportsfile/”SZ9_5684″ (CC license)
share
The Securities and Exchange Commission wants the court overseeing its case against Binance to consider the Terraform ruling.
In a notice of supplemental authority filed Wednesday, the SEC argued that the Terraform ruling — which found that UST, LUNA, wLUNA and MIR are all securities under the Howey test — is relevant to the Binance case because the SEC alleges that the stablecoin BUSD is a security.
The SEC also points out that a prior motion to dismiss — filed by BAM Management and BAM Trading in September — cited Terraform.
In the dismissal motion, BAM argues that,in the case of LUNA: “The money invested in Gram, Kin, or LUNA went to the promoter; the promoter undertook to use that money to build the blockchain, the functionality for the tokens, or to offer tokens with a yield-bearing return; and the investor could receive value if the promoter did what they promised.”
Read more: Judge sides with SEC in Terraform case on securities sales question
Terraform’s case, at the time, did not support the “SEC’s unprecedented theory of an investment contract in this case. In fact, they support BAM’s position,” lawyers argued.
But, in the most recent ruling in Terraform, the judge ruled that Howey is a statement of law.
Additionally, Judge Jed Rakoff said that “Defendants make much of the fact, undisputed by the SEC, that UST on its own was not a security because purchasers understood that its value would remain stable at $1.00 rather than generate a profit.”
“But, beginning in March 2021, holders of UST could deposit their tokens in the Anchor Protocol, which defendants’ efforts developed and which Kwon himself publicly announced would generate ‘by far the highest stablecoin yield in the market,’ with a ‘target’ of ‘20% fixed APR.”
The finding by Judge Jed Rakoff that “offers and sales of UST constituted an investment contract because UST investors could deposit UST into a protocol that Terraform developed and promoted as a profit-yielding opportunity,” support the SEC’s argument against the offer and sale of BUSD, the SEC claimed.
“The court’s analysis of the Terraform defendants’ so-called ‘stablecoin’ UST is particularly relevant to this Court’s consideration of Defendants’ arguments concerning Binance’s so-called ‘stablecoin’ BUSD, and Defendants’ staking-as-a-service, BNB Vault, and Simple Earn programs,” the SEC argued.
Read more: Terraform Labs founder Do Kwon faces US extradition: WSJ
Terraform, following the ruling, said it “strongly” disagreed with the decision that either UST or the other tokens were securities.
Binance and Binance US didn’t immediately return a request for comment.
Don’t miss the next big story – join our free daily newsletter.
Newsletter
Blockworks Daily
Upcoming Events
Digital Asset Summit 2024
Mon – Wed, March 18 – 20, 2024
Crypto’s premier institutional conference returns to London in March 2024. The DAS: London Experience: Attend expert-led panel discussions and fireside chats Hear the latest developments regarding the crypto and digital asset regulatory environment directly from policymakers and experts.
Permissionless III
WED – FRI, OCTOBER 9 – 11, 2024
Pack your bags, anon — we’re heading west! Join us in the beautiful Salt Lake City for the third installment of Permissionless. Come for the alpha, stay for the fresh air. Permissionless III promises unforgettable panels, killer networking opportunities, and mountains […]
recent research
Research
2021 was a massive year for network activity, so naturally protocol innovation and growth followed suit. Perps found true PMF, DEXs continued to launch new primitives, and stablecoins continued to excel.
by Research Team
/
Breaking headlines across our core coverage categories.
Finance
ProShares’ bitcoin futures ETF accounted for substantial flows in lead-up to potential spot fund approval
Web3
The anniversary comes amid rampant speculation about a US spot bitcoin ETF approval
Policy
Bloomberg Intelligence analysts are bullish on January approval. Matrixport’s head of research isn’t. What are others saying?
Finance
Goldman Sachs was previously mentioned in a December amendment from Hashdex
Op-Ed
In a year when global investment in Web3 seemed to be slowing down, APAC investment has been accelerating
Finance
Funds and founders say the extended seeds are a result of heightened Series A requirements and bull market anticipation
newsletter
Blockworks Daily Newsletter
Get the daily newsletter that helps thousands of investors understand the markets.
blockworks research
Unlock crypto's most powerful research platform.
Our research packs a punch and gives you actionable takeaways for each topic.
Blockworks Inc.
133 W 19th St., New York, NY 10011